LendingTree vs Quicken Loans: Choosing the Best Lender for You

ByTop10.com StaffOct.24, 2018

This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Please be advised that the operator of this site accepts advertising compensation from companies that appear on the site, and such compensation impacts the location and order in which the companies (and/or their products) are presented, and in some cases may also impact the rating that is assigned to them. To the extent that ratings appear on this site, such rating is determined by our subjective opinion and based on a methodology that aggregates our analysis of brand market share and reputation, each brand's conversion rates, compensation paid to us and general consumer interest. Company listings on this page DO NOT imply endorsement. Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on this page are disclaimed. The information, including pricing, which appears on this site is subject to change at any time.

LendingTree Vs QuickenLoans
When shopping around for a mortgage, is it best to start your search with a marketplace or by going straight to a direct lender? Put this to the test with a direct comparison between LendingTree​, one of the best online lending marketplaces for finding low mortgage rates, and Quicken Loans, one of the country’s most popular direct lenders.

Types of Loan Programs

One of the marks of a good lender is how many different types of loans they offer. Do they only offer mortgages for home purchases, or do they also offer things like refinancing, home equity loans, and reverse mortgages? Do they typically offer conventional loans, or do they also underwrite government-backed loans and jumbo loans? LendingTree and Quicken Loans both offer a broad range of products and mortgage types to cater to most types of borrowers.

It’s notable that Quicken Loans offers YOURgage, a special fixed-term mortgage with terms of 8 to 30 years and down payment of as low as 3%, on top of its more traditional mortgages.

Loan TypeLendingTreeQuicken Loans
Fixed-rate mortgages (15-year and 30-year)YesYes
Adjustable-rate mortgagesYesYes
Jumbo loansYesYes
Conventional refinancingYesYes
Cash-out refinancingYesYes
Reverse MortgagesYesYes, through One Reverse Mortgage
Home Equity LoansYesNo
Home Equity Line of CreditYesNo
FHA LoansYesYes
VA LoansYesYes
HARP Refinancing;YesYes
USDA LoansNoYes
YOUrgageNoYes

Winner: LendingTree wins this one, because its search function connects borrowers with an unbeatable amount of loans from its network of lenders.

Winner: LendingTree

Rates

Below is a direct comparison of the cheapest rates offered by LendingTree and Quicken Loans at time of writing. LendingTree’s rates are based on the cheapest rate offered by any of its network of lenders for a home purchase in Charlotte, NC, for a borrower with excellent credit score purchasing a home for $250,000 with 20% down payment. Quicken Loans’ rates are based on the best rates offered directly to borrowers.


LendingTree RatesQuickenLoans Rates
30-year fixed3.625%4.625%
15-year fixed3.625%4.125%
5/1-year ARM3.125%3.99

Winner: LendingTree’s ability to draw on the best rates from dozens of lenders gives it the advantage over even the best direct lenders such as Quicken Loans.

Loan Requirements

Most of LendingTree’s network of lenders require the same credit score and down payment as Quicken Loans for the various types of mortgages. For example, for conventional fixed-rate and adjustable-rate loans, LendingTree and Quicken Loans both offer loans to people with a credit score of 620 or more and a standard down payment of 20%. Both can organize conventional loans for as low as a 3% down payment, provided the borrower is willing to meet other conditions, like private mortgage insurance (PMI). The rules for government-backed loans are more or less set in stone, regardless of which lender is underwriting the loan. For example, FHA loans are open to borrowers with poor credit, with down payments ranging from 3.5% to 10%. VA loans are open to qualifying members and veterans of the US Military, National Guard, and Reserves, as well as surviving spouses of service members who died in the line of duty.

Winner: This is a tie, as there isn’t a great deal of difference between LendingTree and Quicken Loans’ loan requirements.

Application Process and Pre-qualification

Quicken Loans prides itself on one of the quickest application processes in the mortgage business. LendingTree likewise connects to several lenders that promise quick and streamlined application processes. Quicken doesn’t specify what documentation you’ll need to provide, but it will likely include the same documentation most other top lenders ask for. This includes:

  • Proof of income such as pay stubs and tax returns.
  • Proof of identity through social security number or copy of government-issued photo ID.
  • A current mortgage statement (if refinancing)
  • Proof of eligibility if applying for government-backed loans such as VA loans

Winner: Again, a tie, given this isn’t a great point of difference between the two and the fact that they both make it quick and easy to apply for a mortgage.

Customer Service

Quicken Loans provides customer support in English and Spanish via phone, live chat, and email, although only during extended business hours. Once you apply, you’ll be connected to a dedicated loan agent who will see you through the process – from application through to origination and closing. Quicken also offers online and mobile applications through its Rocket Mortgage brand.

LendingTree offers customer support by phone and email during extended business hours, but it doesn’t have a live chat option. LendingTree shares your contact details with participating lenders from its network, which is useful if your aim is to secure the lowest rate possible but can be annoying if you don’t wish to receive calls from multiple lenders.

Winner: Quicken Loans wins out for customer service, due to the fact it’s a direct lender and doesn’t share your details with other lenders.

Winner: Quicken Loans

Pros and Cons

LendingTreeQuicken Loans
ProsConsProsCons
Fill out one form to get quotes from multiple lenders

Not a direct lender

Quick application processLive chat isn’t offered 24/7
It takes only a couple of minutes to get loan offersRates are only shown after entering your contact detailsFull suite of loan optionsNo FAQs on website
Check how your credit score impacts your ability to secure great ratesHigh number of calls and emails from different lendersWebsite contains useful educational resourcesThe huge range of options can be confusing

Use LendingTree If

Low rates and APR are the most important thing to you. LendingTree’s main purpose is to connect users to the lowest rates in the market, and it does this successfully – using its powerful search tool to sort through and display deals from some of the nation’s best lenders.

Use Quicken Loans If

You’re looking for personalized service backed by one of the country’s biggest lenders. Quicken Loans offers competitive rates and super-quick processing times, making the mortgage application process as comfortable as it could possibly be.

The Winner: LendingTree

Most people would agree that low rates are the number one most important thing to look for in a lender. With this in mind, LendingTree comes out the winner for providing unrivalled access to the lowest rates in the market for each type of mortgage loan. Having said that, Quicken’s rates aren’t that far behind the market lows, and it provides other benefits that many customers might consider of equal importance to low rates. LendingTree wins, with Quicken close behind.

Overall Winner: LendingTree