We earn a commission from brands listed on this site. This influences the order and manner in which these listings are presented.
Advertising Disclosure

Super Home Warranty Review 2024

Katy Ward

In a Nutshell

If you’re looking for comprehensive coverage for your home’s systems and appliances, Super Home Warranty has a great deal to offer. With 4 plan types (Simple, Secure, Signature, and Lux), its policies include generous payout caps and cover unknown pre-existing conditions. Although its prices are higher than some of its rivals, it does offer a multi-functional app and a full suite of add-ons so you can customize your plan.


  • Generous payout caps
  • Covers unknown pre-existing conditions
  • App available


  • Only available in certain cities
  • More affordable options available

Super Super Visit Site

Super Home Warranty Plans

The provider offers 4 plan types, with the options available to you depending on the state you live in.


Best for basic coverage
Best for protection all home essentials

Best for enhanced coverage

Best for high-tech homes



Built-in microwave

Garbage disposal

Trash compactor

Range exhaust fan

Kitchen refrigerator w/ice maker and dispenser

Clothes washer

Clothes dryer

Air conditioning

Heating system/heat pump


Interior plumbing

Plumbing stoppages

Water heater

Interior electrical

Ceilings fans

Central vacuum

Garage door openers

It’s Covered Upgrade

Smart home devices

Warming and cooling drawers

Enhanced plumbing upgrade

Gas fireplaces and outdoor gas fire pits/pits

Landscape lighting

If you choose a Signature or Lux plan, you’ll also receive an It’s Covered upgrade, which includes the following:

  • Heating: registers and grills
  • Indoor plumbing: faucets and showerheads, pressure regulators, instant hot water dispensers, sewage ejectors, toilets of like quality
  • Water heater: expansion tanks and problems caused by sediment
  • Enhanced stoppage coverage
  • Indoor electrical: built-in lighting fixtures, smoke detectors, and doorbells
  • Range/cooktop/oven: rotisseries, racks, handles, knobs, dials, and interior
  • Lining dishwasher: racks, rollers, and baskets
  • Microwave oven: door glass, interior linings, and shelves
  • Garage door: springs, hinges, and remote transmitters
  • Permits and code upgrades
  • Refrigerant recapture & disposal
  • Equipment disposal
  • Structural modifications 

Optional Add-Ons

You can also add the following to your plan:

  • It’s Covered upgrade (available on Simple/Secure)
  • Enhanced plumbing upgrade 
  • Smart home devices 
  • HVAC equipment incompatibility coverage 
  • Additional refrigeration units 
  • Built-in pool/spa 
  • Saltwater pool/spa 
  • Additional pool pumps
  • Water softener and reverse osmosis 
  • Guesthouse 
  • Septic system 
  • Well pump 
  • Additional built-In refrigerator 
  • Sprinkler system
Super Home Warranty subscription care for your home

Plan Exclusions

You won’t be covered for the following:

  • Known pre-existing conditions
  • Misuse
  • Improper previous repair
  • Missing parts
  • Acts of nature
  • Power surges
  • Accidents
  • Manufacturer defects
  • Chemical, soap, or sedimentary build-up (except water heaters)
  • Pest/pet damage
  • Food spoilage, loss of income, utility bills, additional living expenses
  • Restoration of walls, ceiling, flooring, cabinets, countertops, or painting
  • Property damage 
  • Injury or death
  • Light bulbs, fuels, filters, remote controls, or batteries 
  • Electronic, computerized home management systems 
  • Cosmetic/non-operational components 
  • Systems/appliances in common areas 
  • Upgrades, components, or parts required due to incompatibility
  • Hazardous substances

Super Home Warranty Plan Pricing

The cost of coverage will depend on factors such as the state you live in and your property type.

Using a tool on the provider’s website, we obtained the following quotes for a currently owned home in Washington DC below 5,000 square feet.

Secure plan

Signature plan

Lux plan

Pay monthly 




Pay annually




We then repeated this process for a property below 12,000 square feet being purchased in Maryland and obtained the following:



Pay monthly




Pay annually




We then entered the details of a currently owned property in Texas that is between 5,000 and 7,4999 square feet. We were given the below:


Pay monthly




Pay annually




Overall, we found these prices to be slightly higher than those of some competitors.

When you request a service, you’ll also pay a standard co-pay of $75.

How to file a claim with Super Home Warranty

You can schedule a service request via the provider’s website, mobile app, email, or customer service line.

During normal business hours, the provider will call you within 4 business hours (48 on weekends and holidays) to arrange a time for a tradesperson to visit your home. If the claim is an emergency, however, Super Home Warranty will attempt to expedite the process.

Repair services are available Monday to Friday during regular business hours. 

Although there isn’t a limit on the number of claims, there is an aggregate coverage limit of $30,000, with the following caps on specific items:

  • Dishwasher: $3,000 ($10,000 on Lux plan)
  • Range/oven/cooktop: $3,0000 ($10,000 on Lux plan)
  • Built-in microwave: $3,0000 ($10,000 on Lux plan)
  • Garbage disposal: $3,0000 ($10,000 on Lux plan)
  • Trash compactor: $3,0000 ($10,000 on Lux plan)
  • Water heater: $1,500 per occurrence (Unlimited on Lux plan)
  • Interior electrical: $5,000 (Unlimited on Lux plan)
  • Ceiling fans: $250 per occurrence on ($500 per occurrence on Lux plan) 
  • Kitchen refrigerator w/ice maker and dispenser: $3,000 ($10,000 on Lux plan)
  • Additional kitchen refrigerator w/ice maker and dispenser: $3,0000 ($10,000 on Lux plan)
  • Additional refrigeration units: $1,000
  • Additional washer and dryer: $3,0000 ($10,000 on Lux plan)
  • Built-in pool/spa: $3,000
  • Water softener and reverse osmosis: $1,000
  • Well pump: $1,000
  • HVAC equipment incompatibility coverage: $5,000
  • Septic system: $1,000
  • Brand-for-brand appliance upgrade: $10,000
  • Enhanced plumbing upgrade: $200
  • Warming and cooling drawers: $10,000
  • Sprinkler system and timer: $1,500 ($2,00 on Lux plan)
  • Additional built-in refrigerator: $5,000

Is Super Home Warranty Legit? 

The provider is accredited by the Better Business Bureau and, as of September 2021, has a rating of 2.98 out of 5 on the site. It also has a rating of 3.7 out of 5 on Trustpilot, although this is based on just 8 reviews. While positive reviewers write enthusiastically about its customer services support, others complain of difficulty reaching staff.

What’s Unique About Super Home Warranty

Unlike most competitors, the provider will cover you for pre-existing conditions if these were unknown at your plan start date.

Help and Support

You can contact the company over the phone or through the app. Its customer support hours are Monday to Friday 9am-9pm (ET), Saturday 9am-7pm (ET), and Sunday 10am-7pm (ET). Alternatively, you can contact the provider through its social media channels.

In the event of an emergency, customers can also call the provider 24/7 for immediate assistance.

When we contacted the company via its social media channels, we received a polite and friendly response within 3 working days, which directed us towards the correct department to answer our queries.

If you would like home maintenance tips, the company has a blog that is updated frequently. There is also a detailed selection of FAQs that answered all the questions we had.

What about the Super Home Warranty app?

Super Home Warranty’s app is available through the App Store or Google Play. It allows you to do the following:

  • Schedule appointments
  • Receive real-time updates 
  • View past service appointments
  • Call/message customer support

How to Get Started with Super Home Warranty

If you’d like to take out a plan, the first step is typically to visit the provider’s website to check whether coverage is available in your area. As of September 2021, it operates in the following places:

  • Atlanta
  • Austin
  • Baltimore
  • Chicago
  • Dallas
  • Houston
  • Phoenix
  • San Antonio
  • Washington 

To purchase a plan over the phone or online, you’ll need to provide your:

  • Name
  • Email address
  • Phone number
  • Address

We found the process of applying for coverage extremely simple and didn’t encounter any issues.

How Super Home Warranty Compares to Other Home Warranty Services

Although Super Home Warranty is at the higher end of the price spectrum and its service request hours are less flexible, it offers certain features not available through many of its competitors. For example, it covers unknown pre-existing conditions and allows you to manage your account via an app.

ServicePlus Home Warranty

Global Home Protection

The Home Service Club

Average annual premium





In-network (number unspecified)

40,000 in-network

15,000 in-network

Service call fee


From $45


Service requests

24/7 online and by phone

24/7 online and by phone

24/7 online and by phone during normal business hours

Super Home Warranty vs ServicePlus

When it comes to premium prices, ServicePlus easily beats Super Home warranty, with average premiums of between $419 and $756 compared against $557.50-$1,649. In another point in its favor, ServicePlus will also offer 2 month’s free coverage and limited roof coverage to new customers. While Super’s coverage extends to unknown pre-existing conditions, ServicePlus will not cover any pre-existing conditions, whether known or unknown. Although Super allows customers to manage their accounts via an app, non-emergency claims are only available during business hours, while ServicePlus offers this service 24/7.

Super Super Visit Site

Super Home Warranty vs Global Home Protection

If price is your top priority, these providers are at opposite ends of the price spectrum—with Super quoting us premiums of $557.50-$1,649 and Global Home Protection’s coverage beginning at $299. Customers will face far lower service fees through Global, with rates beginning at $45 compared against Super’s $75. Like many providers in this industry, Global Home Protection doesn’t currently have an app, while Super offers a full-service solution. And, although we received polite and friendly customer service from both providers, we were especially impressed by the speed with which Global responded to our queries and the detail it offered.

Super Home Warranty vs The Home Service Club

Like many companies in this industry, The Home Service Club offers a significantly lower premium than Super, with rates of $552-$799. However, Super does offer a number of features not available with its rival such as covering pre-existing conditions and a comprehensive app. Another important difference between the 2 companies relates to their annual payout caps—while Super has coverage limits of up to $30,000, The Home Service Club places payout caps of between $6,000 and $9,000 depending on the plan you choose. While many similar companies offer 24/7 phone service, both companies operate during business hours, although Super does provide an emergency service.

The Bottom Line

Super Home Warranty provides robust protection for your home’s systems and appliances. Although it is possible to find cheaper coverage elsewhere, we were pleased to see some features often not available through competitors, such as coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions and a comprehensive app.

Frequently Asked Questions
Does Super cover pre-existing conditions?+-

The provider will cover you for pre-existing conditions if the fault had not been identified when your coverage began.

Does Super cover maintenance services?+-

All Super Home Warranty plans include access to maintenance services such as HVAC tuneups and carpet cleaning.

Can I transfer my Super subscription?+-

If you sell your home, you can transfer your coverage to the new owner.

Oxford graduate Katy Ward is a seasoned journalist and editor covering personal finance and software topics for Top10. Over a 15-year career, Katy has worked with several finance titans, including Barclays, Tandem Bank, and Yahoo! Finance.

Copyright © 2009 - 2024 Natural Intelligence Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

Mailing address:

4023 Kennett Pike #50055

Wilmington, DE 19807

Top10.com is designed to help users make confident decisions online, this website contains information about a wide range of products and services. Certain details, including but not limited to prices and special offers, are provided to us directly from our partners and are dynamic and subject to change at any time without prior notice. Though based on meticulous research, the information we share does not constitute legal or professional advice or forecast, and should not be treated as such.

Reproduction in whole or in part is strictly prohibited.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.