We earn a commission from brands listed on this site. This influences the order and manner in which these listings are presented.
Advertising Disclosure

Paychex Review

Catherine Miller

In a Nutshell

Paychex is a long-standing payroll provider, operating since 1971. They’ve developed their all-in-one HR and payroll solution to make your business operations easier and more efficient. The company’s strength is helping you stay compliant with taxes: Paychex not only automates your tax processing, but also provides specialists for consultation. For growing businesses with complex tax needs, Paychex could be a great choice.

pros

  • All-in-one HR and payroll solution
  • Dedicated compliance team to support you
  • Wide range of employee payment options

cons

  • Hard-to-reach customer service
  • Complex system may take time to learn

Paychex at a Glance

9.4
Editorial Score

Integration Capabilities

Integrates with accounting, hiring, HR and other solutions you already use
10.0

Features

Payroll management, tax calculation, reporting and analytics, work schedule and time off, employee training
10.0

Employee Experience

Employee self-service, Employee Retention Tax Credit services
7.0

Reporting and Analytics

Robust workforce analytics capabilities, effortless on-demand reporting that's customizable
10.0

Trials

3 months free
10.0

Paychex Paychex Visit Site

Paychex at a Glance

Best for: Businesses with complex tax needs
Price range: From $39/month + $5/person/month
Benefits & HR: Automated HR processes, Support from HR specialist, Document management, Workers’ comp, Unemployment
Automatic tax filing: Yes
Apps: iOS and Android

Features and Add-ons

Paychex’s payroll comes with a range of features to make paying your employees easier and to help you stay compliant. In addition to the ability to run your payroll in a few minutes via the online portal or mobile app, Paychex gives you:

  • Built-in safeguards to make sure your payroll is accurate. You’ll get notified of any potential issues before you finalize the payroll, and a pre-check service will look out for any mistakes. 
  • Syncing between your Paychex payroll and other accounting and general ledger software, so you don’t need to spend time importing data. 
  • Employee self-service with controlled access to their own payroll so they can see paystubs and W-2s, as well as contact administrators through a live chat. 
  • Employee Retention Tax Credit services. This helps you work out if this credit can be applied to your business and apply it using your payroll data. 
  • Full compliance support from professionals. 

The payroll function is complemented by Paychex’s wider HR solution, which helps you manage your HR functions simply and quickly, with maximum efficiency. Features include the following.

  • Data analytics dashboard to explore how your company’s doing across HR functions, with helpful industry benchmarks.
  • HR process automation.
  • Document management (track renewal times and collect e-signatures).
  • Make sure your organization is compliant with professional assessment, education, and worker classification.
  • Implement a safety program for your organization with help from experts.
  • Dedicated HR professional on hand to support you.

Tax Compliance

Tax compliance is a strong feature of the Paychex service. The payroll software contains automatic tax administration, which will calculate, pay, and file your taxes. With your Paychex subscription, you’ll also have access to dedicated compliance specialists who can help you with federal, states, and local taxes, reporting, and other duties. 

Paychex will also help you work out if you are entitled to tax credits and support you in making your application. This blend of digital and personal support means you can have peace of mind when it comes to meeting your tax obligations. 

Payment Options

Paychex comes with multiple pay options so you can choose the one that suits your business and your employees. You can pay via the web portal or mobile app and choose from direct deposit, paycards, paper checks, and real-time payments. You can even set up pay-on-demand, meaning your employees can be paid before their set payroll date. If needed, you can also delay the taking of funds from your business account for up to 7 days to give you a useful buffer. 

Pricing/Costs & Fees

Paychex offers 3 different plans, each containing a selection of payroll features and aimed at particular business needs. You can sign up for the cheapest plan, Paychex Flex Essentials, online, but for Paychex Flex Select or Paychex Flex Pro, you will need to request a custom quote.


Paychex Flex Essentials
Paychex Flex Select
Paychex Flex Pro
Best for
Small businesses (1-9 employees) in need of a quick and simple solution
Businesses of any size needing enhanced HR support
Larger businesses needing full service HR, payroll, hiring, and onboarding support
Cost
$39/month + $5/person/month
Custom quote required
Custom quote required
Direct deposit and on-site check printing
Mobile app
Employee self-service
Standard analytics and reporting
General ledger report
Dedicated payroll specialist
X
Additional employee pay options (paper checks, check signing, check logos)
X
Garnishment payment service
X
Accounting software integration
X
X
Tax administration
W-2 and 1099 forms
New-hire reporting
Labor compliance posters
Workers’ compensation insurance
State unemployment insurance

X
HR library and business forms
Learning management system
X
Onboarding essentials
X
X
Employee screening essentials
X
X
Handbook builder
X
X
Paycard
Tax credit services
Financial wellness program
Employee Assistance Program
X
X

Paychex Paychex Visit Site

Usability

The Paychex interface is cleanly designed and simple to use, both on the web portal and mobile app. As it’s an all-in-one solution, you log in to just one account to manage payroll, benefits, and other HR functions. On the other hand, it’s a complex system that does far more than just payroll, so might take time to adjust to. It’s worth noting that, while Paychex offers 24/7 support, some customers have found it hard to reach service representatives by phone. 

Conclusion

Paychex has a wide range of features that can help you run your business smoothly, efficiently, and compliantly. Its key strength is helping you deal with taxes: Paychex not only automates much of the tax process, but also gives you access to specialists, so you can make sure you’re on top of your obligations. The ability to pay employees in a variety of ways is also useful. 

Paychex’s payroll is embedded into its wider HR offering, which supports you with your people management in a variety of ways, from document management to employee safety programs. While this can make the product quite complex, it’s useful to have an all-in-one platform. If your business would benefit from the mixed digital and human touch that Paychex offers, it could be a great choice for you. 

Catherine Miller is a lead member of personal finance and pension innovator Maji, where’s she’s responsible for content creation and running Maji’s personal finance masterclass. Miller also holds degrees in English and education, and worked as a teacher before moving into writing about finance for Top10.com. Today, she combines aspects of education and personal finance to help readers make better decisions in finance and beyond.

Copyright © 2009 - 2024 Natural Intelligence Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

Mailing address:

4023 Kennett Pike #50055

Wilmington, DE 19807

Top10.com is designed to help users make confident decisions online, this website contains information about a wide range of products and services. Certain details, including but not limited to prices and special offers, are provided to us directly from our partners and are dynamic and subject to change at any time without prior notice. Though based on meticulous research, the information we share does not constitute legal or professional advice or forecast, and should not be treated as such.

Reproduction in whole or in part is strictly prohibited.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.