Top Exotic Pet Insurance Providers of 2020

Top10.com Staff
Top Exotic Pet Insurance Providers of {year}
Your exotic pet is part of the family, so it's important that they stay healthy and happy with pet insurance that keeps you covered—no matter what.

What is Exotic Pet Insurance?

The best pet insurance companies offer a service for pet owners seeking a financial safety net in case their animal gets sick or injured and requires expensive veterinary treatment. Owners of dogs, cats, and, in some cases, exotic pets, pay a monthly premium for this service, with costs varying based on the age and breed of the animal, what medical costs are covered under the policy, what annual or per-procedure deductible the policy includes, and what percentage of treatment the customer will be reimbursed for by the company.

Best Exotic Pet Insurance Providers 2020

1. Nationwide 

Best for: A wide array of pets, especially birds

  • 24-hour vet hotline
  • Multiple pet discount
  • Use any vet, nationwide

Nationwide is the exclusive provider standard of exotic pet insurance, standing out among competitors who only provide insurance for cats and dogs. This insurance is affordable, covering accidents and illness, exams, lab fees, prescriptions, x-rays, hospital stays and more. Most birds are covered, as well as many amphibians, geckos, gerbils, hedgehogs, iguanas, rabbits, turtles, snakes and more. To enroll, you’ll need to call Nationwide to discuss your pet’s specific health needs with an associate. 

Read the full Nationwide review

Nationwide Nationwide Visit Site

2. Pet Assure

Best for: Pets with pre-existing conditions

  • Call center open 12 hours/day
  • Free quote
  • Accepts any animal

Pet Assure is not technically a pet insurance, it’s a discount health care plan designed for any animal. This makes it a great fit for someone with multiple pets or unconventional animals. All in-house medical services and procedures are included in the plan at participating vets, including dental, exams and x-rays, diabetes management, hospitalization, wellness visits, sick visits, allergies, and cancer care. There are no age limits and no claims to file (or be denied). It includes a free 24/7 lost pet recovery service, so you never have to worry about anyone getting lost. Basically, every procedure you ever need will be cheaper with PetAssure on your side. 

Read the full Pet Assure review

PetAssure PetAssure Visit Site

When Should You Buy Exotic Pet Insurance?

You will get the most value out of your policy if you buy insurance when your exotic pet is young. Providers may have a minimum age requirement, but it is advisable to insure your pet as soon as they pass this threshold, which is no more than a couple months old. Insuring older animals, who are often at greater risk for costly ailments, can still save you a lot of money in the long run, but monthly premiums will be higher. Treatment for serious diseases, such as cancer, can cost in the tens of thousands of dollars. Getting your pet put down is unfortunate no matter the circumstance—but it’s preferable that it be for the sake of humane treatment, rather than because the medical costs are too high. It is important to insure your pet before they get sick, because it is unlikely that a policy will cover a pre-existing condition.

How Does Pet Insurance Work?

Pet insurance prices are specific to the animal in question and the type of coverage you want, so the sign up process begins with you providing information on the provider’s website about the species, breed, age and basic medical history of your pet. You will then get a quote which you can adjust by changing your deductible, reimbursement percentage, annual limit, and coverage plan if the provider has a tiered pricing system.

Once you’ve purchased your policy, you’ll be able to call and get pre-approval for any medical procedure your pet is undergoing to make sure the provider covers it under the policy. Some providers will pay the vet directly, while other providers will reimburse you after you pay the vet. The amount of time it will take to get reimbursed varies, however some providers, commit to processing claims in a matter of days.

What Does Exotic Pet Insurance Cover and How Should You Choose?

  • The extent of your pet insurance policy’s coverage will depend on the provider and plan that you choose. When choosing a plan, coverage you may look for includes:
  • Preventative/wellness care
  • Hereditary conditions
  • Unexpected illnesses and injuries
  • Dental care
  • Diagnostic tests
  • Surgeries
  • Hospitalization
  • Medication
  • Supplements or prescription food
  • Behavioral therapy

As a, exotic pet owner you’ve likely found that the most common costs you have for your animals, particularly young pets, is their routine exams. While some insurers, cover exam costs, others do not. With some insurers, you may have to opt for a more expensive monthly premium to get them included. While such preventative treatment is a common expense, it’s worthwhile to do the math and see if it actually saves you any money. The money you have to add to your monthly premium may be more than your out-of-pocket cost for 1 or 2 annual checkups, depending on the insurance provider and it’s fees.

It is very rare for any pet insurance provider to cover pre-existing conditions. However, some providers will cover conditions that have been cured and have shown no symptoms for at least 180 days.

An unexpected illness or injury that requires diagnostic tests, surgeries, overnight hospitalization and medication can cost more than many pet owners can afford. It’s worthwhile to invest in a plan that covers these costs and prevents a situation in which you are forced to euthanize your pet because you can’t afford treatment. As unpleasant as it is to think about, this should be your number one concern when choosing a pet insurance provider. Emergency care gets costly, quickly, and pet insurance should cover most of the bill.

While these are things that you should insist that your plan cover, there are some other things that you’ll likely have to live without. In addition to not covering pre-existing conditions, it is common practice for insurers to exclude cosmetic procedures, like ear cropping or claw removal, as well as breeding costs.

What are the Costs of Pet Insurance?

Pet insurance costs vary widely, and depend on many factors, including:

  • Breed
  • Age
  • Health
  • Deductible
  • Annual limit
  • Reimbursement level
  • Coverage level

To put it simply, the younger and healthier your exotic pet is, the cheaper a premium you’ll pay. The more you pay, the higher your annual limit and range of coverage will be.

In addition, the amount of deductible you’re willing to pay, your reimbursement level and the amount of your annual limit will also affect your monthly payment. So it is important to understand what these terms mean:

Deductible

This is the amount you pay out-of-pocket before the insurance kicks in. If you have an annual deductible of $1,000, you will pay all expenses up to $1,000, even if your policy covers the procedure. So if your pet’s medical care costs $5,000 in 2019, you will pay $1,000, and the insurer will pay the other $4,000, depending on your reimbursement level.

If you choose a lower deductible, say $50, you’ll pay only $50, and your insurer $4,950. However, paying a lower deductible will make your monthly premium go up.

Reimbursement Level

The deductible isn’t the only cost that you will pay out-of-pocket. The insurer does not pay you back 100% of the cost of a covered procedure. It will generally pay you back somewhere between 70%-90% of the cost. If you choose 70%, your monthly premium will be lower, whereas it will be higher if you choose 90%.

If you have $5,000 of annual pet medical costs and a $1,000 deductible, there is $4,000 remaining to be paid. If you chose a 70% reimbursement level, the insurer will pay you back $2,800. If you chose a 90% reimbursement level, the insurer will pay you back $3,600.

Annual Limit

This is the maximum amount that the insurer will pay for treatment in a given year. If you have a low limit, like $5,000, and your animal ends up having $20,000 worth of treatment, you will have to pay $15,000 out-of-pocket. If you opt for unlimited coverage, the insurer will cover the full $20,000, minus deductible and uncovered reimbursement percentage. Not every insurer allows you to choose a limit—some offer only one option. 

Not every provider allows you the same range of customization, however you will at least have some degree of freedom in deciding how much you pay monthly, and what chance you take of incurring bigger personal costs for illnesses and injuries that occur throughout the year.

So, Which Exotic Pet Insurance is Best for You?

Insuring your pet is a smart move that can potentially save you tens of thousands of dollars. It is essential to choose a reliable insurer that you know will pay your claim when the time comes. While it’s best to insure your pets while they’re young, it’s never too late to sign your friends up for a policy that will make sure they are cared for in the event of an unexpected accident or illness.

Your exotic pets deserve pet insurance that will cover all their medical needs as they age, and you deserve the peace of mind of knowing you can afford any procedure they may require. See our in-depth reviews of the leading pet insurance providers to learn more about policies, plans, deductibles, and more.

Top10.com Staff
Top10.com's editorial staff is a professional team of editors, writers and experts with dozens of years of experience covering consumer, financial and business products and services.